My Photo

The Out Campaign

Atheist Blogroll

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 05/2005

« And Now For Something Completely Different | Main | Going to Church »

Comments

Steven Alleyn

This isn't exclusive to bisexuals, as I'm certain you're aware; my girlfriend, for example (I'm a straight lad) is jealous of my best friend Drew. He and I have a relationship stretching back to our childhood and she loathes the fact that he and I can have conversations that she cannot be a part of.

My solution to the problem was to tell her that I wasn't going to ditch my friends just because I love her and if she didn't like it; tough shit.

But then she knew she wouldn't be able to control things like that when she started dating me; I've got a bit of a gruff personality.

Steph

Oh, so completely amen on this one. The "you can't be friends with someone you could theoretically be attracted to" thing is a huge pet peeve of mine. It's massively sexist in the hetero form (why, going to a basketball game with another man? Obviously you're screwing around, since there's no way a man and a woman could simply enjoy doing something together as friends!) and just generally insulting and needlessly restrictive all around. There was a "For Better or For Worse" strip a year or so ago in which Liz discovering that her boyfriend had a woman visiting his house (with nothing even mildly sexual going on) was treated with such a relationship-ending impact you'd think she'd found them in flagrante.

Noahkins

I found this post. . . disappointing, to say the least.

Now, I completely agree with you regarding the fact that this strain of jealousy is dumb, screwed up, and biphobic.

But, I think that there are two big problems with this post. First, in your analysis leading to the assertion that "the fact that we’re attracted to both women and men makes us ineligible to be friends with anybody, of any gender, ever", you left out, oh, every gender but two. Bisexuals can't hang out with "gay men, straight men, straight women, lesbians. And we definitely couldn’t be friends with other bisexuals". What about genderqueers, or people whose gender is third or fourth, or the rest of the wonderfully gender-interesting people out there? Well, if you're a 'bisexual' in the strict constructionist sense of the word - attracted to two genders (which usually means men and women) - you could, even with the insane jealousy logic, be friends with us. Especially to those of us who aren't attracted to people of your gender.

And what if you're the kind of bisexual person that also has the potential to be attracted to people who are neither women nor men (pansexual/omnisexual)? Then I think that your post should have mentioned people who are neither women nor men in the list of people you wouldn't be allowed to befriend.

This brings me to my second, and more interesting, point. People who are neither men nor women should have been in that list, not only because they would be one of the people bisexuals couldn't spend time with, but because of the nature of your post. To paraphrase you, people who are less than enlightened often ignore bisexuals as part of the queer and trans* movement. But, I think, people who are neither men nor women are ignored more often. So I find it inappropriate that in a post about the neglect of an aspect of the queer and trans* community (bisexuals), you completely disregard a different aspect (people who are neither men nor women).


-Noahkins

PS I thoroughly enjoy your blog, and admire you as a writer and a thinker. That’s why I took the time to write this in response. I hope I didn’t show any disrespect and that my comment wasn’t too (for lack of a better word) mean.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Subscribe/ Donate to This Blog!

Books of mine

Greta on SSA Speakers Bureau


  • Greta Christina is on the Speakers Bureau of the Secular Students Alliance. Invite her to speak to your group!

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz


Powered by Rollyo

Some Favorite Posts and Conversations: Atheism

Some Favorite Posts and Conversations: Sex

Some Favorite Posts: Art, Politics, Other Stuff